Book Review: “Significant Zero” by Walt Williams

Do you even know who Walt Williams is? He’s not to be confused with Walter E. Williams, the late economics professor at George Mason. No, this Walt Williams is considerably less famous. I bet you haven’t heard of him, and that’s not your fault.

I note this only because most of my readers are also writers, and Williams happens to be the writer of one of the greatest works of fiction of this century. A mind-bending tale of psychological horror that deserves to rank with anything Stephen King ever penned. And yet his name is scarcely known in this ill-shadowed tract of country! Quelle bizarre!

The reason is that Williams writes video games, and games are rarely known for their writing, except maybe when their writing is bad. This has changed somewhat in recent decades, but alas, I sometimes think the attempts to cure the lack of recognition for game writing has been worse than the disease. By that I mean that in the well-meant attempt to recognize game writing, bad game writing has been elevated in an attempt to put it on a level with other media. While there are plenty of well-written games, they are rarely the ones that are most well-known.

Significant Zero is Williams’ recounting of his time in the game industry, from when he first fell in love with games as a young boy playing Mario on the NES to when he nearly burned himself out in a furious crunch to complete work on a major title for a big game publisher.

In between, Williams catalogs all the little unglamorous struggles that go on behind the scenes in the industry, the petty battles between the egos of different members of the team, and the constant tension between art and commerce. I’m sure much the same things went on during the Renaissance. Orson Welles’ speech about the cuckoo clock from The Third Man comes to mind.

Most interesting is Williams’ description of his relationship with his boss, whose identity is cloaked with the pseudonym “The Fox” in the text. Their relationship is a textbook example of the mentor/apprentice dynamic described in Daniel J. Levinson’s The Seasons of a Man’s Life. Having read that book, I knew where the relationship would go from the start, but that doesn’t detract from the drama of it one bit. Quite the reverse. It’s an awful and awesome thing to see a prophecy come true.

One interesting thing is that, by his own account, Williams is kind of a jerk. He freely admits this. Like many another artistic genius, he has a tendency to arrogance and self-aggrandizement—which is often a cover for his own insecurities. This combination of traits produces someone driven to produce great work to appease his own inner demons. These demons, of course, are insatiable, and so the push for greatness is relentless. This sort of person is incredibly inspiring to read about and absolutely infuriating to know. Williams knows this, and doesn’t shy away from portraying himself in a harsh, honest way.

He paints the game industry itself the same way; describing the way he physically destroys himself while working to finish a game. He writes about completing a game with a sense of physical and mental exhaustion that those around him compare to someone who has been in war. Although, honestly, comparing Williams’ memories of writing video games to, for instance, Ernst Jünger’s memoir of World War I trench combat, it seems clear that Jünger had more fun. I’m not sure what that means, but it’s got to mean something.

Speaking of war, this is where we need to discuss Williams’ magnum opus, the 2012 war video game Spec Ops: The Line.

Spec Ops: The Line is Williams’ commentary on violent video games, modern warfare, man’s inhumanity to man, and so forth. A game that takes everything you think you know about modern military shooter games and flips it on its head.

The trouble is, it’s impossible to talk about it with people who have never experienced it. Partially, this is because it all hinges on a massive plot twist that you have to understand to fully “get” the game, and part of it is that the game is so brutally visceral that merely describing it is woefully inadequate. You just have to see it for yourself. Sorry.

But what I can say about it that is of interest to writers is this: the plot twist I mentioned? It’s so integral to the story, I assumed it had been part of the plan from the beginning. But no; Williams reveals it was introduced in an 11th-hour rewrite when the game was already mostly finished. I realize you can’t appreciate this without knowing what it is, but trust me, it’s insane that something so incredibly transformative to the whole story could be added so late. It’s a cliché to say “well, we’ll fix it in post” but that is exactly what happened here. The story before the twist was added sounds incredibly disappointing. The story after is one of the best ever written, and certainly one of the best video game stories penned by someone not named Chris Avellone.

This book is a must-read for anyone engaged in creative endeavors, but especially writing. Williams has many insights into the artistic process, but perhaps the one that stuck with me most of all was this:

Our universe is one of logic and laws. To create is to shatter those laws, to reach inside yourself and produce a thing where once there was none. The universe doesn’t like that. It will set everything it has against you–time, space, and everything in between. When the fight is over, it’s easy to forget how hard it was. 

What's your stake in this, cowboy?