I posted about the movie The Haunting the other day and Thingy confirmed in the comments that the remake wasn’t very good. That’s so often the way with remakes. The great director John Huston was right when he said:
They can’t make them as good as they are in our memories, but they go on doing them and each time it’s a disaster. Why don’t we remake some of our bad pictures – I’d love another shot at ‘Roots of Heaven’ – and make them good?
I found out the other day that they’ve remade the famous N64 video game Goldeneye 007—again! And today the “Black Mesa” Half-Life mod was released. Granted, that’s just a fan-made effort to satiate the demand for a new Half-Life game, so it’s a bit different.
Huston said it–they should do remakes of lousy movies, books and games. Not necessarily the worst of the worst, but the ones that had potential and fell flat. The game Daikatana was actually a good concept, it just didn’t work out. They should take another try at it. Alfred Hitchcock remade his own film The Man Who Knew Too Much. And I think many of H.P. Lovecraft’s stories could have benefited from a reworking, especially The Shadow Out of Time.
Oh, well. I guess it makes economic sense that only popular things get remade, but it makes no artistic sense.