I don’t know about you, but I find stupid protagonists in stories to be annoying. And there’s nothing more irritating than seeing an obvious plot twist coming down the pike, and having the hero not realize it. This happens in several of Lovecraft’s stories, and I find it to be a real mood-killer.
I assumed for a long time that everyone was like this. But then it occurred to me that maybe some readers enjoy that. There is a certain satisfaction, I guess, in seeing what is going to happen before the characters do. You can feel like you are smarter than somebody else, even if they are only a fictional character. (Having never experienced that first-hand, I wouldn’t know if it’s much fun.)
Personally, I like to be surprised by a story. Which do you prefer: the comfort and satisfaction of knowing what’s coming, or the fun of being surprised by plot twists?